Santa Clause is gasping for your vote!
Or, do you prefer the logo submitted by the Mayor of North Pole Bryce Ward?
North Pole to unveil logo 6/23/2013 FDNM
On March 10, 2011, Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation issued a Nuisance Abatement Order to the owner of two outdoor wood boilers heating two duplexes located across the street from Woodriver Elementary School.
Residents need to continue to notify the Alaska DEC of any nuisance problems experienced due to smoke emissions from these OWBs. DEC inspectors must be notified of a problem and be able to verify a violation of the order for DEC to take the emitter to court. The order is not a ticket, as DEC does not have authority to issue tickets on air quality violations. The order itself carries NO fine. Only when a violation of the order is found, could there be any consequence. If found guilty in court, penalties could be up to $10,000 and a jail term up to 1 year.
Smoke emissions from the OWBs have plagued the University West neighborhood since the fall of 2008. High concentrations of fine particulate pollution may have also affected the Dale Road neighborhood and Watershed less than 1 mile away south and east across the Chena River.
Here are recent photos of the two outdoor wood boilers provided by Santa. He’s been volunteering in Woodriver Elementary School and visiting friends with children in the neighborhood and told us,
If I could stuff the stockings of all those students and children full of clean air, I would. Sharing the photos is something I can do to help them.”
Click on the photo to view a larger image. Some of these photos were taken after the Nuisance Abatement Order was issued on March 10, 2011.
Posted in Coal Burning Appliances, FNSB Air Quality Program, Local Air Quality Ordinance, Santa Stories, State Responsibility & Regulations, tagged Farmers Loop, Farmers Loop Extension, Santa Claus, smoke plague, Sourdough Farmers Loop Market, Steese Highway on January 21, 2011|
Poor Santa. He just can’t find clean air in either his hometown or Fairbanks these days. The Air Quality Index at the downtown monitor reads UNHEALTHY again today, Jan. 21, 2011. Santa’s especially dismayed to see the coal boiler near the corner of the Steese Highway and Farmers Loop on Farmers Loop Extension pouring it out again. He shared his story and his recent photos.
Here’s his note to Clean Air Fairbanks:
“Driving by Farmers Loop and the Steese Highway, the missus and I couldn’t help but notice the smoke coming from this outdoor boiler. It was thick, dark, bluish, stinging to our eyes and throats, and smelled of coal or garbage. I’m keeping a list, and this guy isn’t nice. This time we reported it DEC and the Borough. Perhaps if they don’t care that Santa’s plagued by this smoker, they’ll respond to your complaint. How can nothing be done to protect the Sourdough Farmers Loop Market employees and those who live nearby? All the people going by on the Steese breathe this coal smoke day after day and still nothing is done? If this smoke doesn’t this smoke meet the standards of “public nuisance” in state regulation 18 AAC 50.110 and borough code 8.21.020 G I’ll eat my red hat. Click on the photos to view a larger version for yourself.”
Posted in Coal Burning Appliances, Local Air Quality Ordinance, Santa Stories, State Responsibility & Regulations, Your Smoke Photos & Videos, tagged defend children, defend neighborhoods, EPA sanctions, feel the smoke, front lines in our smoke battle, local control, Mayor Luke Hopkins, No violation found., overtime for inspectors, prohibit overtime, reluctant enforcement, Santa Claus, Santa shopping in Fairbanks, see the smoke, smell the smoke, smoke inspectors, smoke pollution free-for-all, smoke regulation, smoke relief, State control, State vehicles for inspectors, stop air pollution, taste the smoke, worsening air pollution every year on January 12, 2011|
For years now local residents have pleaded for relief from harmful levels of air pollution. Now our economy is at risk from EPA sanctions. Still think there’s no problem? Look again.
This coal smoke event occurred on a January weekend. Santa came to Fairbanks to buy CO detectors at Home Depot. He found the detectors, but the coal stench reeked so much that it was all he could do to grab a few paint chips for the sleigh (reds) as Dasher and Blitzen pulled him right out the door and away. No lingering in the smoke loading zone, for goodness sake.
DEC wasn’t able to take Santa’s call with his complaint. How could they? They weren’t there. Even with our riches of oil, the State can’t afford overtime for the scant handful of qualified air quality inspectors or even let them use State vehicles so they can get out there and defend our neighborhoods and children.
Residents can see the smoke, smell the smoke, feel the smoke, even taste the smoke when they cough. Neighborhoods are the front lines of our battle against smoke. Yet, Santa tells us no one in DEC has found an air pollution violation in our borough. Ever. That gets under Santa’s rosy skin because he knows the pollution, year by year, is growing worse.
There is no record that Alaska DEC has ever levied a fine, ordered air pollution to stop, or even found an air quality violation from a woodstove, wood boiler, or coal boiler heating appliance in the borough. Santa is sure DEC sees the smoke too, but their reports all say, “No violation found.”
DEC could do a better job prohibiting smoke if they didn’t prohibit overtime for their inspectors. Operators time the smoke events for when no one will be around to respond to complaints. Two exceedance days a year–that’s one weekend–is all it takes to keep us in nonattainment status; currently, we exceed state and federal standards dozens of days each winter.
Does DEC sound like the state department you want to entrust with air quality control for our community? Borough Mayor Luke Hopkins has just forwarded a voluntary air program to the Assembly which, if approved, will tie the hands of borough government and trigger State control.
We’re not reassured. If the Borough washes its hands of the messy job of enforcement, then it falls to Governor Parnell’s department that disdains smoke regulation even more. DEC thinks smoke isn’t any different from the annoyance of a neighbor’s barking dog, and it’s best left to the locals. Reluctant enforcement is what has given us this smoke pollution free-for-all, worsening each year.
Tell the Borough not to hand over responsibility for protecting our air to DEC. Speak up Thursday, January 13, 2011, 6 pm.
The Agenda for 1/13/2011 meeting has a link to the draft ordinance 2011-03, the voluntary air quality ordinance, but the link doesn’t work. Here’s the current draft: 2011-03, draft version 1/13/2011 [517KB]. Review the current local Air Quality Ordinance 2010-28 (approved 6/10/2010) and Proposition A: the Home Heating Protection Act (approved by voters Oct. 5, 2010 and certified Oct. 12, 2010).
Posted in Air Sampling Results, FNSB Air Quality Program, Local Air Quality, On Schools & Children, Our FNSB Community, Santa Stories, tagged 24-hour average, air pollution map, air quality monitoring, asthma, bronchitis, cautionary statements, children, Dr Lori Verbrugge, fnsb, heart conditions, highest PM 2.5 concentration, hourly monitoring, increased mortality, indoor air, judging particulates in your area, lowest concentration, lung conditions, moving out of North Pole AK, north pole, North Pole Elementary, pm 2.5, Santa Claus, school air filtration, smoke sources, Snowman Lane on January 5, 2011| 1 Comment »
Santa isn’t laughing about the new hourly smoke reports for North Pole. He knows smoke is serious trouble. He and Missus Claus are getting up in years and want to be make and deliver presents for many more. Plus, he’s all about kids and elves and wants his hometown to be safe. Santa’s “Ho, Ho, Ho” sounded more like “hack, hack, hack” when he sent Clean Air Fairbanks the map of possible North Pole smoke sources you can view at the end of this post.
Real-time, hourly PM 2.5 monitoring reports from the Fairbanks North Star Borough for North Pole are now viewable online at Live Air Quality Data — FNSB AQ Monitoring. The monitoring site is at the North Pole Elementary School.
Here’s how you get the hourly AQ reports for North Pole: when the map of Alaska comes up, click your computer mouse on the blue dot over Fairbanks, then click “ClickStationInfo” to see the monitoring data for 1-hour (PM2.5L 1hr) and 24-hour (PM25L_24). While it says, “Last Received” this mini report may omit some hourly reports you can find in the monthly tables (see below).
[Difficulties? The map of Alaska will not load unless you allow web content that was not delivered securely—click “no” on security warning. Also, if it still isn’t working, try a different web browser as some do not work with this application.]
With a little more elbow grease you can even get month-long tables of hourly data at Live Air Quality Data — FNSB AQ Monitoring. Click on “Data Reports” on the left column, then beneath that click “Matrix.” In the box, select Station “North Pole Elementary” and Monitor “PM2.5L 1hr.” Then set the start date for the first day of the month you want: 12/1/2010 or 1/1/2011 both work. [Set the start date yourself; the calendar seems hinky.] Then push “GenerateReport” at the bottom of the box. These tables report the most current data every hour (without omissions unless the monitor isn’t working), the lowest PM 2.5 concentration recorded that day (Min), the highest concentration (Max), and the 24-hour average concentration (Ave).
You think the monthly tables aren’t user friendly? Be thankful Santa has them at all! Wouldn’t it be great to have more monitoring sites on-line? Limited availability of public information has hindered general understanding of the severity and primary sources of our PM 2.5. Clean Air Fairbanks continues to shine light where we can.
What’s the North Pole AQ monitoring data show? Based on the monthly tables, 7 exceedances over EPA’s 35 micrograms/cubic meter standard were recorded in December 2010 (only half the month reported data) and 2 exceedences have been recorded so far in January 2011 (thru 1/5). The highest hourly PM 2.5 concentrations recorded in Dec. 2010 at the North Pole Elementary monitoring site was 119.3 micrograms at 11 pm. Not a good time to walk Rudolph and the other reindeer. During the winter of 2009-2010, the borough sniffer vehicle recorded an instantaneous reading (not hourly) concentration of over 2,000 micrograms at Lineman Ave and Dawson Road in North Pole. When would you say is a good time for Santa, Mrs. Claus, and the elves to load up the sleigh and move?
How’s North Pole compare with Fairbanks? The FNSB Air Quality Index reported the 24-hour average at the downtown monitor (675 7th Ave) was 21.1 micrograms as of 4 pm on 1/5/2011. For the preceding 24-hour period (from 5 pm the previous day to 4 pm on 1/5/2011), the average in North Pole was 55.6, significantly higher than in downtown Fairbanks. The maximum hourly concentration recorded at the North Pole site on 1/5/2011 was 94.2.
When is it necessary to take health precautions? View Judging Particulate Levels in Your Area from EPA. According to this table, when hourly concentrations hit 81 micrograms, even healthy children should “limit prolonged exertion.” “Unusually sensitive individuals” including children with lung conditions, such as bronchitis or asthma, or heart problems should be protected at lower PM 2.5 concentrations. Recent studies have found increased mortality with short-term exposure to PM 2.5 concentrations less than 20 μg/m3, considerably below the “health-based” 24-hour standard of 35 μg/m3. [See Dr. Lori Verbrugge, Alaska Division of Public Health, 2009 Symposium Presentation.]
North Pole Elementary School Interim Principal Rosita Bryant-Wilburn and school nurse Diana Drath can now use Live Air Quality Data — FNSB AQ Monitoring to determine for any given hour 1) whether recess should be held outside or inside, 2) whether athletic practice and competitions should be held, 3) whether to take extra precautions to protect health-compromised children such as the 24 students at North Pole Elementary who have notations of “asthma” in school medical files, and 4) when it is time to turn off school air ventilation system to prevent drawing dirty air inside. The public availability of North Pole Elementary’s PM 2.5 air monitoring reports turns up the heat for school indoor air testing as indoor air is not filtered at any school in the borough. Air in classrooms and halls may be as bad as what’s outside. To raise these concerns with North Pole Elementary’s interim principal, contact her directly: Rosita Bryant-Wilburn, phone: (907)488-2286, firstname.lastname@example.org. Tell her Santa sent you!
Find North Pole Elementary School, 250 Snowman Lane, on Google maps. Visit the North Pole Elementary School School District website. North Pole Elementary is attended by 483 students, including 24 students with notations of “asthma” in school medical files, and students are supported by 30 teachers and 34 other school district employees. The health of school district employees as well as students is at risk from elevated PM 2.5. Hundreds more students attend North Pole Middle School (585 students, 48 asthma-notations) and North Pole High School (781 students, 41 asthma notations), located within 2,000 feet of North Pole Elementary where the PM 2.5 readings are taken.
Santa knows who’s been naughty and who’s been nice so he gave us this map: Map of possible PM 2.5 sources near North Pole Elementary School (from DEC) [124KB]. The North Pole Elementary School is located near “Snowman” in the lower left hand corner of the map. The flags are color coded: Green (23) = indoor woodstove; Red (22) = Outdoor Wood Boiler; Blue (4) = Outdoor Coal Boiler. Some of the wood boilers burn coal also. The flags are not comprehensive; many areas have not been researched. Other sources of PM 2.5 such as diesel vehicles, such as idling near the school, are not shown. Contrast the number of flagged potential sources (49) with the thousands of people living nearby.
Santa promises not to give out any more lumps of coal in North Pole. Be on the lookout instead for stockings loaded with dry firewood. Santa will be in touch to let you know what you can do to get him out of smoke trouble.